Episode 27: Colonialism in Board Games (AV Club #2)

Daniel Hilty & Kevin Taylor — Sun, 02 Apr 2023 15:00:00 -0400

Terra Nullius – a null land, or "nobody's land"

TOPIC: Playing Colonialism – Board Game Ethics on the Homo Ludens YouTube Channel

Hosts: Fred Serval & Luis Aguasvivas
Mary Flanagan, co author of the book, "Playing Oppression"
Brian Train - War game designer
Cole Wehrle - Root, Pax Pamir
Jason Perez - Shelf Stories, consultant for Puerto Rico 1897
Topic: Exploring problematic but common theme of colonialism in board games – going to "exotic lands," "exploring them," "exploiting them" - creating illusion that lands are empty and/or that indigenous people are resources to be used, without agency.

God is concerned with questions of justice. Liberation Theology - Gustavo Gutierrez. "God's preferential option for the poor."
We want to play games that don’t promote hate, racism, or injustice.
We can play games that invert power and domination, or question it – games as morality and learning

Mary Flanagan - you can't just retheme these games. The mechanisms themselves are not morally neutral. They were developed to simulate colonialism.
Are game mechanisms every morally neutral? What about abstract games?
“There is a hunger for nontraditional narratives” – Jason Perez

Whom are we erasing for the sake of an abstracted game mechanism? For example, in Ticket to Ride, we are erasing Native American population cleared out for these railroads, we are erasing the workers.
Who has agency and how can we represent them? Brian Train talked about this.
Cole Wehrle - Giving tribes agency in Pax Pamir
_Spirit Island _doesn’t question the whole system, it just reverses it.
Jason Perez – Giving agency to the "little person." This is certainly in keeping with religious teachings across the board, including Jesus.

Ask questions – is this a game that teaches something contrary to my beliefs? Ali Karar spoke of not playing games that promote wine-making and alcoholic drinks.
Jason Perez - It does no good to call people "bad people." He said, "these are generally nice people who are relying on tropes to sell products." Instead, ask, "how can we broaden sales? How can we appeal to an even wider audience?"
Amanda Ripley - High Conflict. "It does no good to humiliate others." Humiliation always leads to high conflict.
What are common goals that we can all agree to?
This takes hard work and creativity.

NEXT EPISODE - "SPIRITUAL LESSONS FROM NEGOTIATION GAMES"

CALL TO ACTION:

Links:

Play Saves the World - Episodes Tagged with “Colonialism”